Canons / Natural / More Musical / 6. The Circle




     Thesix preceding pagesdealt with a very specific form of Natural Canon, a Voice-leading A Swing, in which : (a) there were no metamorphoses within the canon (only possibly to paste in the assembling) and (b) there was no Rhythmic structure whatever in the original canon, no beginning, no end, only vague Binary Groupings because a fundamental Metamorphosis 0 Swing consists of only 2 chords, one in each direction. This canon became more and more musical (and melodic) as the Rhythmic structure asserted itself.
     TheCircle, on the other hand, (a) makes constant use ofMetamorphosis 1, and (b) possesses a definite Rhythmic structure, with beginning and end, with a fixed length of 8 chords. However, these 8 chords can be grouped in 3 very different ways with varied and interesting results.
     Each chord of the Circle will be written as a full BarWhole note. This will offer us an opportunity to see that Bars behave, among themselves, exactly the same way that beats of a bar do and that Rhythm has the sameAlternationof Beats and Off-beats at all levels, large as well as small.

Cell-size, Voice-leading, and Direction
If thecell is Binary, with 2 chords (bars), 1 on the Off-beat and 1 on the Beat,
      Voice-leading Cwill be used, with its binary Orbit Chain (3-2),
          and the voices will descend a second at each cell.
If thecell is Ternary, with 3 chords (bars), 2 on the Off-beat and 1 on the Beat,
      Voice-leading Awill be used, with its ternary Orbit Chain (3-2-10),
          and the voices will ascend a third at each cell.

The Binary Circle

Shape
The Binary Circle, with its 4 cells, is in the fundamentalaA / cA, aC / cCshape,
     abasic binary formwithout any transformation of ablation.

ncgraphcircle01

This is what the Rhythm Graphics look like for all the binary Circles,
     whatever the number ofEntities.

One Entity

The beginning
The very first circle we saw was in theDiatonic Major Mode.
C+7/ F+7, Bm7-5/ Em7, Am7/ Dm7, G7/ C
ncbincircle01
We have here one large diatonic 4-cell entity,
     with aMOTRIXon each chord except the last.

Dominantized
C7/ F7, Bm7-5/ E7, A7/ D7, G7/ C
ncbincircle02
We still have only one large 4-cell entity,
          with aMOTRIXon each chord except the last,
     but here each chord except the BUCKLE (in Bar 3) has beendominantized.

Two Entities

There are 2 ways of dividing the complete large entity into 2 equal smaller entities,
          in both cases by having aReal Triadin Bar 4 -
     1. with a Real Triad of E (major),
          part of an Ante-1/Dominant temporary cadence (Bm7-5/ E) in A minor, and
     2. with a Real Triad of E minor,
          part of a Dominant/Tonic temporary cadence (B7/ Em) in E minor.

Temporary Dominant in the Middle
Only the E major Real Triad is dominantized,
     all the other chords are diatonic.
C / F+7, Bm7-5/ E, Am / Dm7, G7/ C
ncbincircle03
NOTE that theMOTRIXs of Bar 1 and Bar 5 have been removed by a1(3) substitution,
          leavingMOTRIXs only atLevel +1, in Bars 2, 3, 6, and 7,
     to avoid re-diatonicizing the G# to G with a weak Inward Chord (Am7),
          and allowing theMEDIANG# to resolve naturally to A.

Temporary Tonic in the Middle
Only the Buckle is dominantized,
          actually by borrowing the B-F#FRAMEabove the Window,
     all the other chords remaining diatonic.
C+7/ F+7, B7/ Em, Am7/ Dm7, G7/ C
ncbincircle04
NOTE that we have aNeapolitan Sixthprogression here, between F+7and B7,
     in which it preferable to leave out theCOMMON TONEline, which starts on G.

Four Entities

Temporary Tonics in each Cell
Each Off-beat (odd-numbered) Bar will be dominantized
          (Bar 7 is already dominantized in its diatonic state),
     each Beat (even-numbered) Bar being a Diatonic Real Triad,
          producing Dominant/Tonic temporary cadences in F, Em, Dm, C.
C7/ F, B7/ Em, A7/ Dm, G7/ C
ncbincircle05
NOTE that we still have the Neapolitan Sixth progression here,
     and that theCOMMON TONEline has been left out.

The Ternary Circle

In order to have Ternary grouping in the 8-chord circle, we must evidently add 1 bar. This doubly-ternary group of 9 bars is the result of 2 ablations in the binary group of 16 bars by (a) ablation of bars 1-4 to produce TernaryLevel +2+3and (b) ablation of bars 5, 9, and 13 to produce TernaryLevel 0+1(in other words, removal of the first quarter of the whole 16-bar group, and then removal of the first quarter of each of the 3 remaining large quarters). The 9 bars left are the original Bars 6-7-8, 10-11-12, 14-15-16. They will henceforth below be numbered Bars 1-9.

One Entity

The originalVoice-leading A Circlehad only 8 chords,
          but it was evidently in Ternary Groups.
     In order to make it completely Ternary, it will be necessary to add another chord.
          1. This can be achieved by adding another TONIC chord at the end -
C+7/ F+7, Bm7-5, Em7/ Am7, Dm7, G7/ C, (C)
nctercircle01
          2. It can also be achieved by adding another chord at the beginning,
                    in this case a DOMINANT chord,
               which gives it a much clearer Ternary form.
G7, C7/ F7, Bm7-5, E7/ A7, D7, G7/ C
nctercircle02
          NOTE that all the chords (except the BUCKLE) have been dominantized,
               to avoid the over-powering effect of the opening DOMINANT
                    when all the other diatonic chords are weak.
          NOTE also how effective the diatonic BUCKLE is in this specific rhythmic position,
               especially with its flat fifth in the Bass Voice.

Shape
The Ternary Circle has been transformed from the fundamentalaA / cA, aC / cCshape,
     into acA, aC / cCby the ablation of the first quarter,
          with 3 bars in each ternary cell.

ncgraphcircle02

This is what the Rhythm Graphics look like,
     for the Ternary Circle, whatever the number of Entities.

Three Entities

Temporary Tonics in each Cell
Instead of binary Dominant/Tonic temporary cadences,
     we will now have ternary Ante-1, Dominant/Tonic temporary cadences, in F, Am, C.
Gm7-5, C7/ F, Bm7-5, E7/ Am, Dm7-5, G7/ C, with the flat fifth in the Bass Voice.
nctercircle03
NOTE that each Temporary Ante-1 has a minor7-5shape/sound,
     typical of the diatonic BUCKLE.
We may possibly have found the "ideal" Ante-1 sound -
     The diatonic BUCKLE, once considered the "ugly ducking" of the diatonic circle,
          might very well be a lovely swan when used as an Ante-1 (temporary or not).
Why ?
     Because the ANTE-1 (Bm7-5in A minor),
          is the shadow of the Sharpening DOMINANT (Dm6)
               and contains the SecondLeading Toneof the TONIC (the F),
                    the first Leading Tone (the G#) being in the Flattening DOMINANT (E7).

The Fibonacci 8 Circle

In the Ternary Circle, we had produced TernaryLevel 0+1and TernaryLevel +2+3. In the Fibonacci 8 Circle, the 4 Levels are fused together, creating one singleLevel 0+1+2+3. Of the 9 bars left in the Ternary Circle (6-7-8, 10-11-12, 14-15-16), one more will be removed (Bar 10) leaving only the original Bars 6-7-8, 11-12, 14-15-16. They will henceforth below be numbered Bars 1-8.

Shape
The Fiboncci 8 Circle is also in the ternarycA, aC / cC3-cell shape,
     with only 2 bars in the centralaCcell.

ncgraphcircle03

This is what the Rhythm Graphics look like,
     for the Fibonacci 8 Circle, whatever the number of Entities.

One Entity

C+7, F+7/ Bm7-5, Em7/ Am7, Dm7, G7/ C
ncfibcircle01
We have here one large diatonic 3-cell entity,
     with aMOTRIXon each chord except the last.

Three Entities

Cm7-5, F7/ Bb, E7/ Am, Dm7-5, G7/ C

ncfibcircle02

We have here three 1-cell entities,
     with aMOTRIXon chords 1-2, 4, and 6-7,
          and Real Triads with substitution 1(3) on chords 3, 5, and 8.
NOTE that -
     in ternary cell 1 (cA, Bars 1-2-3) and in ternary cell 3 (cC, Bars 6-7-8),
          we have Ante-1, Dominant / Tonic entities, in Bb and C,
     but in binary cell 2 (aC, Bars 4-5),
          we have a shorter Dominant / Tonic entity in Am,
     thus 3 entities in Bb, Am, C.
NOTE also that -
     in ternary cell 1 (cA, Bars 1-2-3) and in ternary cell 3 (cC, Bars 6-7-8),
          Voice-leading A is used and the voices rise a third,
     but in binary cell 2 (aC, Bars 4-5),
          Voice-leading C is used and the voices drop a second.

Two Circles

It is merely by chance that the Circle falls into a Binary form. There are only 7 chords in the Window, but a Circle requires repetition of the initial TONIC chord at the very end, giving us a total of the convenient binary 8. Progressing through 2 circles would thus produce 15 chords (2x7+1) which could conveniently be divided either into 3 groups of 5 or 5 groups of 3 (both Fibonacci numbers).

Three Groups of Fibonacci 5

Shape
These 3x5 Circles will also have a ternarycA, aC / cCshape,
     with 5 bars (chords) in each section,
          6 entities (cadences) in all.

ncgraphcircle04

This is what the Rhythm Graphics look like for these 3x5 Circles.

C7/ F, Bm7-5, E7/ Am, D7/ G, Cm7-5, F7/ Bb, E7/ Am, Dm7-5, G7/ C
nc2circles01
We have here 6 entities,
     in 3 groups of binary-ternary, in temporary keys Am, Bb, C,
          with descending Voice-leading C in each binary cell, and
          ascending Voice-leading A in each ternary cell.

Five Groups of Fibonacci 3

Shape
These 5x3 Circles will also have a ternarycA, aC / cCshape,
     with 6 bars (2 cells) in the first and third sections
               and 3 bars (1 cell) in the second,
          5 entities (cells) in all.
However, the first section has been transformed
     from 2 ternary cells to 3 binary cells,
          producing 6 entities (cells) in all, from the original 5, see below.

ncgraphcircle05

This is what the Rhythm Graphics look like for these 5x3 Circles.

C7/ F, B7/ Em, A7/ Dm, Gm7-5, C7/ F, / Bm7-5, E7/ Am, Dm7-5, G7/ C
nc2circles02
NOTE the cheating at the beginning, in thecA-
     instead of being 2 groups of 3 bars, it is 3 groups of 2 bars, a large hemiole,
          to facilitate the range for a vocal performance,
               by having 3 Voice-leading C descending cells,
                    instead of 2 Voice-leading A ascending cells.
     Instead of 6 entities, there would have been 5 without the hemiole cheating.
NOTE also that -
     the first 3 binary cells are the same as the first 3 cells of
          theBinary Circle in Four Entities(an octave lower),
     and the following 3 ternary cells are the same as the complete
           Ternary Circle in Three Entities.

Two Fibonacci 8 Circles

Two Fibonacci 8 Circles will produce 16 chords (bars) and it will be necessary to add a chord at the beginning as we did for the Ternary Circle of 9 chords.

Shape
These 2x8 Circles will have a complete binaryaA / cA, aC / cCshape,
     with 3 bars in the first (aA) and third (aC) sections
          and 5 bars in the second (cA) and fourth (cC),
     6 entities (cadences) in all.
Each Fibonacci 8 circle will have the sameshapeas when we had only one.

Gm7-5, C7/ F, B7/ Em, Am7-5, D7/ G, Cm7-5, F7/ Bb, E7/ Am, Dm7-5, G7/ C
nc2circles03
NOTE that the first circle is in the DOMINANT key (in G),
     and the second circle in the TONIC key (in C),
          as it was in theFiconacci 8 Circle in Three Entities.


Previous Top Next