Definition A syncopation can best be defined as - the prolongation of a note attacked on anOff-beat to the nextBeat.
It is usually anticipated (attacked sooner) , but we have left a section open at the end, for cases where it is retarded (attacked later).
Anticipated Syncopations
One may anticipate by different amounts (note-values) and we will catalogue these amounts by the correspondingrhythmic level- aanticipation atLevel -2, aanticipation atLevel -3, and aanticipation atLevel -4.
Level -2
In a bar (composed of a) with the basic Melo-rhythmic pattern the third beat (the first) can be anticipated by a, producing the pattern
A kind of snap If there is a breath after the, as is often the case, we have the same process as when a normalFeminine Rhymeis transformed into asnap. In other words, a snap is a form of syncopation, but not all syncopations
are snaps. Thispattern is frequently used atLevel -3with shorter note-vales, as.
Level -3
In a bar with the basic Melo-rhythmic pattern the first(on the second beat ) can be anticipated by an, producing the pattern which we find inRudolph The Red-Nosed Reindeer as well as in the Habanera Melo-rhythm (frequently written as a triplet).
In a bar with the basic Melo-rhythmic pattern, a typical tango rhythm, the first(on the fourth beat ) can be anticipated by a, producing the pattern less frequently used than the previous example.
However, in the same basicpattern, the whole(of the third and fourth beats ) can be anticipated by an, producing the pattern the typical Freilach rhythm, which has been used in popular music of
all nations, including the French, inY'a d'la joieby Charles Trenet.
Let's not forget the basicpattern, where the whole(of the third and fourth beats ) can also be anticipated by an, producing the pattern. the typical Charleston rhythm, so dear to Gershwin.
These patterns will re-appear with shorter note-values inLevel -4.
Level -4
In Caribbean folk-music, one often finds the basic. ' pattern syncopated into_. ' by anticipating both the secondand the.by a as well as the whole last beat, also by a.
Retarded Syncopations
It took us a long time to elaborate the operation of retarded syncopations. They seem so much more insidious and uncertain than anticipated syncopations. Syncopations are a little like Non-chordal tones (which are a displacement in Pitch
of a Chordal Tone) in that they are also displacements but, in this case, in Time. Since songs are composed in the syncopated state, we usually have no "unsyncopated" version with which to compare. We finally found one, originally written without syncopations, later transformed into a syncopated version. Comparing the 2 versions enabled us to establish the nature and position of retarded
syncopations. The songs which follow are all quite well known and can be found in most Fake-Books.
La Cucaracha
Analysis of the Melo-Rhythm The song is composed of - a Chorus which consists of 4 cells - a split cell with a pick-up and Feminine Rhyme, followed by a Kinetic Off-beat with a Masculine Rhyme on the Beat, these 2 cells are repeated for the second half, 2x(p3F=p3F= K3M), and a Verse which also consists of 4 cells - a Kinetic Off-beat with a Feminine Rhyme on the Beat, which appears 3 times, and the same Kinetic Off-beat with a Masculine Rhyme on the Beat, for the fourth
cell. 3x(K3F=) K3M. NOTE that the Verse consists uniquely of the second (or fourth) cell of
the Chorus, with fusion (Feminine Rhymes) applied to the first 3 cells.
Original Ternary Version in 3/4 In the original Mexican version in 3/4 atLevel -1without any syncopations the Melo-rhythm of the 8-bar Chorus is composed of2x( \ ' / \ / . ) and the Melo-rhythm of the 8-bar Verse is composed of3x( / ) / ..
Transformation to Binary Version in 4/4 When this is transformed into the Basic Binary 4/4 atLevel -1 the Melo-rhythm of the Chorus is now2x( \ ' / \ / _ ) and the Melo-rhythm of the Verse is now3x( / ) / .
American Syncopated Version in 4/4 In the American Syncopated Version in 4/4 atLevel -1 the Melo-rhythm of the 8-bar Chorus is now 2x( \ ._' / ._ \ / _ ) whererepresents anrest, and the Melo-rhythm of the 8-bar Verse is now 3x( / ._ ) / .
By comparing the syncopated version with the unsyncopated 4/4 version, we see that
- (a) theat the beginning of bars 3 and 7 of the Chorus and bars 1, 3, 5, and 7 of the Verse are Retarded Syncopations, (b) the._in bars 1, 2, 5, and 6 of the Chorus and the._in bars 2, 4, and 6 of the Verse are Anticipated Syncopations.
The Rule
Syncopations are placed so as to enlarge the breath between phrases. 1. Retarded syncopations are placed after a breath (at the beginning of a phrase). 2. Anticipated syncopations are placed before a breath (at the end of a phrase). 3. Retarded syncopations seem to apply only to the very first note(s) of a phrase but not to the anacrusis, as we will later see (inJamaica Farewell). 4. Anticipated syncopations apply to any of the other notes of a phrase, especially
the last one(s).
Other Examples
Jamaica Farewell This song is written in 4/4 atLevel -1and is composed of - A Verse which consists of 4 cells (8 bars), allK3F= where cells 2 and 4 have pick-ups,p2K3F= which prevent any possibility of Retarded Syncopations at the beginning
of bars 3 and 5. However, cells 1 and 3 do not have pick-ups, which allows them the same which we found inLa Cucaracha. A Chorus which also consists of 4 cells (8 bars, 9-16) also allK3F= where cells 3 and 4 have pick-ups,pandp3 which prevent any possibility of Retarded Syncopations at the beginning
of bars 13 and 15. However, cells 1 and 2 do not have pick-ups, which allows them the same. NOTE that, in the whole song, we have 8F=s, not a singleM. The pick-up between the Verse and the Chorus, at the end of bar 8, should normally bebut is anticipated to to permit theRetarded Syncopation at the beginning of bar 9 which would not, otherwise, have the required breath preceding
it. This breath between the Verse and the Chorus is now staggered - the breath in the Melo-rhythm is at the very end of bar 8, and the breath in the lyrics is before the last 2 notes of bar 8, before
the words "But I'm".
There are many variations (both notes and note-values) in the different versions of
this song. In the 2 versions which we examined, we found (with a tie indicated underscored,
as_) In bar 2,_and_ In bar 3 (Verse 3),and In bar 4,_and_ In bar 5,and In bar 7,_and In bar 10, scale degrees 224 and 234 In bar 12, scale degrees 113 5 and 123 5 In bar 16,_and_ The first version is blatantly inconsistent in its syncopation of the 8F=s 3 anticipations of only 1 note,_, in bars 2, 4, and 16, 3 anticipations of 2 notes_in bars 6, 8, and 10, as well as. 3 anticipations of 3 notes (imposed by the words)_, in bars 12 and 14. The other version is more consistent in its syncopation of the 8F=s 6 anticipations of 2 notes_in bars 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, and 16, as well as the 2 inevitable anticipations of 3 notes_, in bars 12 and 14. A good candidate for Analysis
Food for thought Might it be possible that - if 2 notes are retarded in the opening, 2 notes should be anticipated in the closing_, and if only 1 note is retarded in the opening, only 1 note should be anticipated in the closing_? There is certainly more work to do.
The Basic Un-syncopated Version - Verse 1 consists of / ' \ / ' \ / ' \ / ' . The Chorus consists of / ' \ / ' \ / ' \ / ' . The Basic Melo-rhythm of Cell 1 of the Chorus is the same as that ofAura Lee, Mary Had A Little Lamb, Polly Put The Kettle On, London Bridge. One could easily syncopate these songs in a Calypso style.
From This Moment On This song is written in 2/2 atLevel -2. For present purposes of examining Retarded Syncopations, we will only examine Cell 1, composed of bars 1-4,K3M, which is syncopated at both ends, 2 Retarded notes at the beginning and 1 Anticipated note at the end
,_ / written here \ _ / _\ . This is, so far, the only song we found where aK3Mis syncopated at both ends - InLa Cucaracha, theK3Mis not syncopated at the end, and InJamaica Farewell, we have noMs, onlyF=s. TheAs, of a completeAABA are composed ofK3M K1F= K2F= K2M, with an added cell at the end of the lastA. a most unusual combination. Another good candidate for Analysis
The Basic Un-syncopated Version - Cell 1 consists of / . the same as Cell 2 ofAura Lee.
Desafinado This song is also written in 4/4 atLevel -2. For present purposes of examining Retarded Syncopations, we will examine mostly Cells 1 and 2, each composed of 4 bars (1-4 and 5-8),K4F-, which only have 2 Retarded notes at the beginning,. / ._ written here \ . / ._\ . These 2 cells are only the first half of the firstA(of a completeAABA) which consists of 16 bars,K4F- K4F- K4F= K4F-. Our "Food for thought" inJamaica Farewell(above), leads us to wonder if the last 2 notes of Cells 1 and 2 should not be Anticipated so as to correspond to the 2 Retarded notes at the beginning,. / _. all the more so that the dotted rhythm in bar 3 corresponds to
that in bar 2 with which it has no real rhythmic alliance. Another good candidate for Analysis
The Basic Un-syncopated Version - Cells 1 and 2 each consist of \ / _\ , atLevel -2, which we would prefer to write / _atLevel -1, a very simple and basic Melo-rhythmic pattern, quite similar to that found inFrom This Moment On.
Bernie's Tune Another song written in 4/4 atLevel -2. Here, we will examine only Cell 1,K4F=, eachAof the completeAABAbeing composed of 2 such cells, which have 2 Retarded notes at the beginning and 1 at the end, / .__ written here_\ / .__\ . NOTICE - the ternary grouping of notes 1-4 and 5-8 ins (ors), and the repeat of the opening(the second indicated_) at the very beginning of the cell, an interesting and unusual innovation.
The Basic Un-syncopated Version - Cell 1 consists of \ / \ , atLevel -2, which we would prefer to write / atLevel -1, the basic Rumba Melo-rhythmic pattern.
Button Up Your Overcoat Another song written in 4/4 atLevel -2. Here, we will examine mostly Cell 1,F+F=, Cell 2 beingK4F-, eachAof the completeAABAbeing composed these 2 cells. Cell 1 has - 2 Retarded notes at the beginning and 1 Anticipated note at the end
of the Off-beat, _, written here \ _, and 2 Retarded notes at the beginning of the Beat, / .__, written here \ . NOTICE the auspicious use of Feminine Rhymes in the completeF+F= K4F-, with F+andF=on Split and Fused Cell 1, and K4andF-on Kinetic Cell 2.
The Basic Un-syncopated Version atLevel -2- Cell 1 consists of \ / \ , which we would prefer to write / atLevel -1, and Cell 2 consists of \ / _\ , which we would prefer to write / _atLevel -1.
Suggestions for Cell 1 - The first note seems a little over-retarded, by arather than by an. Reducing this Retarded Syncopation to anwould give usfor Bar 1. Anticipating the last 2 notes of Bar 2,_would balance the beginning. It might be interesting to check recordings to see how singers interpret
these syncopations.
Spread (and Dot) Syncopations
Some forms of syncopation have left us baffled for a long time. The most refractory
case was the principal theme of theChopin Waltz in B minor, Op. 69 No. 2 posthm. This waltz opened a door to a new Spread Syncopation concept, as was the case forLa Cucarachaconcerning Retarded Syncopations.
The Chopin Waltz in B minor
The piece opens with this Melo-rhythm -_/_/ with the Pick-uptied to the followingacross the first bar-line. This tied Pick-up reappears regularly duringthe first 16 bars of the waltz. Although this tied note complies with the usual definition of a syncopation as "the prolongation of a note attacked on an Off-beat to the next Beat", it does not comply with the exigencies of either Retarded or Anticipated
Syncopations.
The first note being in reality a.and the second note an, it seemed natural to suspect that the un-syncopated state might be/ even if the first was on the Off-beat and the second on the Beat. The Melo-rhythm_/_/would thus have been //before applying the Spread performance practice.
In theoriginal Spread performance practice, the 2 originals were in the same and the resulting.did not produce a Syncopation, as the snapped.did. However, in thisChopin Waltz, the 2 originals were NOT in the same and the resulting.DID produce a Syncopation. For future reference, we will note that this Spread Syncopation was over aLevel -1Bar-line.
This extension of the Spread process, (which includes a reversal of the rhythmic positions of the 2 original values
involved), seemed sufficiently daring to deserve further examination and, especially, further
application.
The Bach Fugue in Eb minor
InRhythm/Preface/The Unknown Container/1995, we examined the Rhythmic nature of thesubjectofBach's Eb Minor Fugue, First Book of the Clavier, to conclude that it was in 3/2 time and not in 4/4 time as written by the
author. However, we did not mention its binary origins before the ablation into ternary
form, nor did we mention the nature of its syncopation, even if we were convinced, at the time, that there was truly a normal
syncopation involved. We now suspect that there might rather be a Spread Syncopation involved here, and we will now examine both possibilities, the Anticipated and the Spread
Syncopations.
The Anticipated Syncopation The Melo-rhythm of thesubjectof this fugue being. / . / , if the.is an Anticipated Syncopation, it should have been the firstin the next, producing / / , with the next 2 notes also "pushed back" at the end, and aWhite Christmas-style Melo-rhythm at the beginning, a fairly complex fundamental (pre-syncopation) version.
The Spread Syncopation With the same Melo-rhythm. / . / , if the firstafter the.should be given fullvalue, the basic Melo-rhythm would have been / / , a much more fundamental version, with all its evens.
The Fundamental Binary and the Spread Syncopation With the binary Melo-rhythm (in 4/4 bars). / \ . / and application of the Spread Syncopation, the basic Melo-rhythm would have been / \ / with even more evens.
The Beethoven Symphony No. 8, First Movement
The third theme of the First Movment of the Beethoven Symphony No. 8 in F major, Opus
93 seems dangerously close to producing a Dot Syncopation across a bar-line which would correspond to the Spread Syncopation of theChopin Waltz in B minor. The Melo-rhythm of this theme consists of - in 3/4_\_'_/_'_\_ / _ with theat the end of each Pick-up (bar) tied over the Bar-line. The reason we said "dangerously close" is that, technically, to be a Dot Syncopation, thisshould be tied to aand not to another, as is the case here, with, across the Bar-line,,Rudolph style. This is a most interesting borderline case which certainly deserves mention.
Other Examples
There will certainly be more to say on the application of Spread (and Dot) Syncopations.
The 3/4-6/8 Performance Shift
Performing in 6/8 a song originally conceived and generated in 3/4 (seeRed River Valley) often produces an interesting syncopation. Where and why does this happen ? 1. If we examine the sixs in 3/4 and in 6/8, we see that - the first and second (as well as the fifth and sixth)s are placed Beat, Off-beat in BOTH cases, but the third and fourths (in the middle) are placed Beat, Off-beat in 3/4 and Off-beat, Beat in 6/8. 2. If the third and fourths are tied (by aor by a.), there will be a syncopation in the 6/8 (not in the 3/4), as the hemioles inDark Eyes. 3. If the second and third (or, more probably, the fourth and fifth)s are tied (by aor by a.) there will be a syncopation in the 3/4 (not in the 6/8), as in theBach Fugue in Eb minor of Book 1. 4. If the bar is disposed (with any further subdivision whatever of these values, but no ties between
them) there will no syncopations in either the 3/4 or the 6/8. The association between syncopations and the 3/4-6/8 Performance Shift seems a promising
one.